Outside of school assignments, I have rarely written anything. When I was
younger, I attempted to keep a journal, but the entries are few and far between.
Sometimes, I would write stories about my life, but I would never share what I
wrote with anybody and these eventually became forgotten. Now, my writing is
limited to class assignments, texts, short emails, and Facebook updates. The last three of these are also few and far between. There hasn't ever been a time
where I would just sit down and write something extensive for fun. For this to
occur, my grade had to depend upon it.
As for what my grade depended on, there have been few writing assignments I have enjoyed and many I have
not. I enjoyed the many creative writing assignments in elementary school.
These activities allowed me to use my own thoughts and think outside the box. I
loved coming up with strange ideas and incorporating them into my
stories, but I never enjoyed sharing my stories. As I progressed through the years, my writing style was changed by
force and necessity. My writing had to be more structured, less creative, and
much longer. My grades depended on these factors and I was determined to get good grades. These changes created a dislike of writing within me. As I look back on middle, junior high, and high school, there were few
assignments I enjoyed completing. These assignments were ones where I wrote about my
life and my opinion in my own words. There was little to no set structure. What I created did not rely on someone else's writing, as did my many essays about novels and research topics. I was able to use my thoughts
and my words. One particular
assignment I remember was a poem I wrote for my AP English Literature course at
the beginning my senior year of high school. It was a "Where I'm From" poem based on the poem by George Ella Lyon. I
loved this assignment. I was able to write about what made me me. I spent a lot
of time perfecting my poem and I was pleased with the final result. Nobody
could judge my work wrong because it was all about me and I'm always right on
the subject of me. On the other hand, the assignments I did not enjoy were the exact
opposite of this. These required me to either research a topic or read a novel
and produce some opinion about it. My writing was based on what I found during
research or while reading a novel and was composed of some other author’s thoughts.
It was not my own voice speaking in the essays I wrote. In addition, I felt my essays were never good
enough. There was always something wrong with what I wrote. I'd turn in most of
my assignments with a feeling of failure, even though I never received a
failing grade when my writing was returned. These feelings, along with many others, have led me to believe today that I am not a writer.
Because of my
experiences writing, I will give my futures students many options on how to express their ideas and
understanding. I don't want to restrict them to a single
method, such as writing, because everyone has strengths and weaknesses. I want
my students to feel comfortable and be proud of what they produce. I don't want them to become stressed by any particular assignment. I want them to enjoy math the way I do.

Stacy,
ReplyDeleteYour post was really great. I can't believe you fret about writing. You are great at it. I too wish people could see my thoughts. It would make a lot of things easier. I definitely agree that we need to give our students options to express their ideas and understanding of the concept. Thank you for your ideas.
Larisa
I really worry about my writing, too, especially when I am submitting an article. I check everything ten times, but eventually I get to a point where I just have to hit send. Even when articles are published, I try to avoid re-reading what I wrote because it is very painful to me.
ReplyDeleteIt is amazing how emotional of a process writing can be. If it's true for us as "successful" adults, how much more true it will be for our students. That's a really important point to remember when we are reading and grading writing. Thanks for a beautifully well-written posting!
I thought it was interesting that you said, "I seek to impress those who read my work and I always feel insecure about what I produce." I bet a lot of people feel that way about writing. I wonder sometimes if that means that we are being too narrow in our definition of what constitutes "good" writing. I really liked your description of what made your favorite assignments special: "I was able to use MY thoughts and MY words...Nobody could judge my work wrong because it was all about me and I'm always right on the subject of me." As educators we could help students develop an enjoyment of writing by allowing them creative liberties; they should feel free to be themselves and write about what matters to them.
ReplyDelete